Best Sellers Oils & Vinegars

FREE Shake It! Dressing Recipe Bottle with an oil & vinegar purchase. Automatically added to cart on qualifying orders. Limit one per order. Excludes gift sets. Available online only while supplies last.

22 products
Sort by
Sort by
Best Seller
Bottle of Caramelized Garlic Infused Olive Oil with golden oil on a white background Bottle of Caramelized Garlic Infused Olive Oil beside pizza, salads, pasta, bread, roasted garlic and a dish of dark sauce on a wooden table
Caramelized Garlic Infused Olive Oil
From $14.00
228 reviews
Best Seller
Bottle of Barrel Aged Dark Thick Sweet Balsamic with a black cap on a white background Bottle of Barrel Aged Dark Thick Sweet Balsamic on a charcuterie spread with flatbread, tomato salad, grapes and a dish of balsamic
Barrel Aged Dark Thick Sweet Balsamic
From $13.00
141 reviews
Best Seller
Bottle of Sicilian Lemon Infused Olive Oil with a yellow lemon label on a white background Bottle of Sicilian Lemon Infused Olive Oil beside waffles, lemons, a berry topped salad and a glass of syrup
Sicilian Lemon Infused Olive Oil
From $14.00
113 reviews

LET’S SHAKE THINGS UP:

FREE Shake It! Dressing Recipe Bottle with an oil & vinegar purchase

Best Seller
Bottle of Garlic and Herb Infused Olive Oil with golden oil on a white background Bottle of Garlic and Herb Infused Olive Oil beside pizzas, a green salad, bread and a dish of oil on a wooden table
Garlic & Herb Infused Olive Oil
From $14.00
56 reviews
Best Seller
Bottle of Sweet Cream Butter Infused Olive Oil with golden oil on a white background Bottle of Sweet Cream Butter Infused Olive Oil beside waffles, a stick of butter, cookies, popcorn and a glass of syrup
Sweet Cream Butter Infused Olive Oil
From $14.00
96 reviews
Best Seller
Bottle of Meyer Lemon White Barrel Aged Balsamic with pale golden liquid on a white background Bottle of Meyer Lemon White Barrel Aged Balsamic beside lemons, a berry parfait, a fresh salad and a sparkling drink
Meyer Lemon White Barrel Aged Balsamic
From $13.00
99 reviews
Best Seller
Bottle of Summer Peach White Barrel Aged Balsamic with pale yellow liquid on a white background Bottle of Summer Peach White Barrel Aged Balsamic beside fresh peaches, croissants, a salad and glasses of a sparkling drink
Summer Peach White Barrel Aged Balsamic
From $13.00
105 reviews
Best Seller
Bottle of Vine Ripened Raspberry White Barrel Aged Balsamic with an orange award badge in the corner Bottle of Vine Ripened Raspberry White Barrel Aged Balsamic beside a fruit salad, croissants, pink drinks and fresh raspberries
Vine-Ripened Raspberry White Barrel Aged Balsamic
From $13.00
45 reviews
Best Seller
Bottle of Smoked Barrel Aged Balsamic with a black cap and dark liquid on a white background Bottle of Smoked Barrel Aged Balsamic beside grilled steak, corn on the cob, vegetables and grilled chicken
Smoked Barrel Aged Balsamic
From $13.00
58 reviews
Best Seller
Bottle of Blood Orange Infused Olive Oil with a red label and golden oil on a white background Bottle of Blood Orange Infused Olive Oil beside waffles, a fresh salad, blood oranges and a dish of syrup
Blood Orange Infused Olive Oil
From $14.00
74 reviews
Best Seller
Bottle of Tuscan Herb Infused Olive Oil with a black cap and golden oil on a white background Bottle of Tuscan Herb Infused Olive Oil beside a pizza, salads, potted herbs and a dish of oil
Tuscan Herb Infused Olive Oil
From $14.00
23 reviews
Best Seller
Bottle of Harvest Fig Barrel Aged Balsamic with a black cap and dark liquid on a white background Bottle of Harvest Fig Barrel Aged Balsamic on a table with fresh figs, strawberries, cheese, charcuterie and a tart
Harvest Fig Barrel Aged Balsamic
From $13.00
37 reviews
Best Seller
Bottle of Black Garlic Tamari Barrel Aged Balsamic with a dark label and a round badge on a white background Bottle of Black Garlic Tamari Barrel Aged Balsamic beside steamed buns, sushi, a small dish of dark sauce and garlic
Black Garlic Tamari Barrel Aged Balsamic
From $13.00
44 reviews
Best Seller
Bottle of Black Truffle Infused Olive Oil with a black cap and golden oil on a white background Bottle of Black Truffle Infused Olive Oil among a vegetable basket, flatbreads, salads and tomato dishes
Black Truffle Infused Olive Oil
From $20.00
33 reviews
Best Seller
Caramelized Garlic Infused Olive Oil and Barrel Aged Dark Balsamic Bottles of Caramelized Garlic Infused Olive Oil and Barrel Aged Dark Balsamic with red grapes, a dish of oil and focaccia
Caramelized Garlic Infused Olive Oil & Barrel Aged Dark Balsamic
From $27.00
Best Seller
Bottles of Sicilian Lemon Infused Olive Oil and Vine Ripened Raspberry White Barrel Aged Balsamic side by side on a white background Bottles of Sicilian Lemon Infused Olive Oil and Vine Ripened Raspberry White Barrel Aged Balsamic with fresh raspberries and lemon slices
Sicilian Lemon Infused Olive Oil & Vine-Ripened Raspberry White Barrel Aged Balsamic
From $27.00
Best Seller
Bottles of Tuscan Herb Infused Olive Oil and Meyer Lemon White Barrel Aged Balsamic side by side on a white background Bottles of Tuscan Herb Infused Olive Oil and Meyer Lemon White Barrel Aged Balsamic with lemon slices and fresh basil
Tuscan Herb Infused Olive Oil & Meyer Lemon White Barrel Aged Balsamic
From $27.00
Best Seller
Everyday Flavor Collection with a bottle of olive oil, a bottle of dark balsamic and jars labeled Black Garlic and Rosemary on a white background Everyday Flavor Collection bottles and jars with red grapes, rosemary and garlic on a wooden table
Everyday Flavor Collection
From $54.90
Best Seller
Fresh Mediterranean Collection with bottles labeled Lemon and Cucumber and jars of Citrus Dill and Tzatziki seasoning on a white background Fresh Mediterranean Collection bottles and jars beside lemons, cucumber slices and fresh herbs on a wooden table
Fresh Mediterranean Collection
From $52.90

LET’S SHAKE THINGS UP:

FREE Shake It! Dressing Recipe Bottle with an oil & vinegar purchase

Best Seller
Bottles of Garlic and Herb Infused Olive Oil and Dark Balsamic of Modena side by side on a white background Bottles of Garlic and Herb Infused Olive Oil and Dark Balsamic of Modena beside red grapes, a dish of oil, focaccia and fresh basil
Garlic & Herb Infused Olive Oil & Dark Balsamic of Modena
From $27.00
Best Seller
Classic Italian Collection with a bottle of olive oil, a bottle of dark balsamic and jars of Roasted Garlic and Bruschetta seasoning on a white background Classic Italian Collection bottles and seasoning jars beside tomatoes, red grapes, peppers and garlic on a wooden table
Classic Italian Collection
From $63.85
Limited Time Flavor
Bottles of Blood Orange Infused Olive Oil and Cara Cara Cherry White Barrel Aged Balsamic side by side on a white background Bottles of Blood Orange Infused Olive Oil and Cara Cara Cherry White Barrel Aged Balsamic with an orange, cherries and sliced blood oranges
Blood Orange Infused Olive Oil & Cara Cara Cherry White Barrel Aged Balsamic
From $27.00